Middle and high schoolers study the constitutional precedent of the electoral college, as well as its place in historical and modern elections, with an engaging social studies lesson plan. Proposals to abolish the electoral college, though frequently put forward, have failed largely because the alternatives to it appear more problematic than is the college itself. The electoral college system has in the past led to the election of three minority presidents, namely, national republican john quincy adams in 1824, republican rutherford b. Pros and cons of the electoral college there has been one faithless elector in each of the following elections.
It does not assure victory to the person whom majority of americans favor. Pros and cons of the electoral college today, many people think that the electoral college should be abolished and that the total popular vote should determine the president. The electoral college is the electors from each state and it comes together every four years to select the president and the vice president of america. The cons are that people living within very populous states are being ignored because of consideration for other states. His electoral college victory in the face of popular vote defeat, the second such occurrence in. The trouble with the electoral college cities, metro areas, elections and the united states duration. Exploring the electoral college overview database of k. Students will view a video about the structure of the electoral college, learn about north carolinas importance in the 2016 presidential election, and participate in an electoral college simulation. Electoral college proscons and alternatives lesson plan for. We, the people, do not elect the president and vice president directly by popular vote.
If the election is a close one, it is easier to recount the electoral college scores. Currently, each state gets a number of electors equivalent to the number of its members of the house, plus two for its senators. Volume 4, issue 3 should the electoral college count. Pros, cons, electoral, election, republic, vigilante, processes, democracy, ghana.
Free study material for students taking sat1 homework help. Pros and cons of the electoral college by corey bishop on. In 2016, hillary clinton won the popular vote while losing in the electoral college. Stephanie schorow, news office correspondent october 20, 2008. It is composed of 538 staterepresentative electors to match the 435 house representatives, 100 senators, plus three for. If no candidate receives a majority, house of representatives elects president twoparty system a. What are the pros and cons of the electoral college. Many people try to eliminate the electoral college but there are also.
Helps prevent a recount by using the electoral college you are ensuring that the results of the election are certain, for the most part. The advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college show us that the system, while imperfect in some ways, has been a beneficial force in the elections held in the united. Exploring the electoral college overview database of k12. It could be said that the electoral college was created for a different time in this country, but by some degree of fortune and foresight it is one. The electoral colleges winnertakesall system causes campaigning only to swing states. This discourage people from participating in the polls. Electoral college proscons and alternatives share my lesson. Research on the us electoral college including pro and cons arguments for keeping it in presidential elections. Thinking about the political impacts of the electoral college. Exploring the electoral college overview in this lesson, students will learn about the history and structure of the electoral college. Source for connecting students to college opportunitysuccess collegeactsat. Lastly, circle the numbers of the specific arguments that you find the most convincing on the side that you agree with. The electoral college is one of the many compromises written into the t united states constitution in 1787. It provides a clean, widely accepted ending to the election most of the time.
Conference weighs electoral college pros and cons mit news. Oct 20, 2008 the chair of the conferences steering committee, alexander s. Apr 14, 2011 i have to write a paper for government class where i have to come up with three pros and three cons of having the electoral college. Antiterrorism, crime and security act 2001 part 4 immigration and asylum implementationsince this measure was known to step beyond the bounds of article 5 of the echr, the government included section 30 to allow for a derogation an opt out, claiming that since there was a state of emergency threatening the life of the nation just one interpretation of the war on terror which. Read the following pros and cons of the electoral college. How it works in contemporary presidential elections congressional research service 2 of this eventuality, which occurred previously in 1876, 1888, and 2000. Aphu phd, huazhong university of science and technology. If every vote counts, why do we need the electoral college. Both parties generally spend less resources on campaigning in these safe states, and pay more attention to the needs of electors in swing states, such as. Nov 10, 2016 posted in notes on the collapse and tagged cons, disenfranchise, election, electoral college, presidential, pros, pros and cons, pros and cons of the electoral college, rogue elector on 10 november 2016 by gnerphk.
Even the selection of a president and the vice president has its pros and cons. A look into the electoral college here are some of the more major pros and cons to the current practice. May 18, 2018 the electoral college gives small states more weight in the political process than their population would otherwise confer. Disadvantages and advantages of electoral college connectus. Pros and cons of electoral college by breana noble thursday, 02 jul 2015 11. Then, they will decide which system would be best in electing the president. The term college refers to a decisionmaking group such as the college of cardinals, which elects the pope for comprehensive discussions of the development and operations of the electoral college systemits pros and cons and possible reformssee league of women voters of the united states, who should elect the president. Nov 14, 2016 ahh, the electoral college a source of much boredom, confusion, and frustration for americans, especially among young voters. A collection of great sites for kids from the american library association college actsat. The fact that the electoral college was originally designed to solve one set of problems but today serves to solve an entirely different set of problems is a tribute to.
Parade outlining common arguments for and against our electoral system. Belenky, visiting scholar in the center for engineering systems fundamentals, proposed that the president should be chosen by a majority of the nationwide popular vote and popular vote majorities in at least 26 states, even if hisher opponent wins the electoral college. The year is 1986, in the texan resort town of lajitas, a municipality with a population. This skews significance only on sparse and small populated. Jun 23, 2010 the electoral college is the electors from each state and it comes together every four years to select the president and the vice president of america.
The advantages of the electoral college may outweigh the. Brought to life by article two, section ii of the u. This electoral college proscons and alternatives lesson plan is suitable for 7th 12th grade. Pros, cons about electoral college the electoral college. One benefit is that candidates dont only go to populous stateswhich would disenfranchise voters from rural and small states, each vote in a small state has. We should preserve the electoral college, but lower by two the number of electors allocated to every state. The electoral college gives small states more weight in the political process than their population would otherwise confer.
Aug 19, 2015 without electoral college, getting the popular vote simply means a win. The electoral college provides some balance to this. The electoral college nc essential standards for american. A candidate could be elected without the popular vote. Dec 20, 2016 brought to life by article two, section ii of the u. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment ratified june 15, 1804, the fourteenth amendment ratified july 1868, and the twentythird amendment ratified mar. Should the electoral college be replaced by the direct election of the. It is important to know the advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college system to be able to weigh in on all. After many elections, there are often calls to abolish the electoral college method of choosing our president and vice president. Students will view a video about the structure of the electoral college, learn about north carolinas importance in the 2016 presidential election, and participate in. It is composed of 538 staterepresentative electors to match the 435 house representatives, 100 senators, plus three for district of columbia. For example lets take california has a bigger population then mosts states, it would only be fair if it was electoral college. The electoral college preserves the voice of states with lower populations and more rural areas, occupy theory noted. Nov 10, 2012 the electoral college pros and cons after many elections, there are often calls to abolish the electoral college method of choosing our president and vice president.
Lets take a closer look at some of the pros and cons of electoral college. The pros and the cons talks that although america makes the boast that as a nation, she leads in the movement of studentshare our website is a unique platform where students can share their papers in a matter of giving an example of the work to be done. Pros and cons of the electoral college essay sample. The pros and cons of the electoral college youtube. Pdf the birth of 1992 democracy in ghana has called for a. Then decide if you think that the electoral college should remain or be abolished. Finally, students will participate in a class debate over the pros and cons of the current system. There is an important debate on whether or not the electoral college should be reformed or even suppressed. The pros of the electoral college is that it acts as an equalizer amongst the states, protecting the less populous states from being drowned out by california. Start studying the electoral college pros and cons. This election result is sometimes referred to, particularly by proponents of electoral college reform, as a wrong. Reforming the electoral college with the districtpopular plan. Keywords united states, new york, california, united states of america, welfare. Pdf the pros and cons of electoral processes encompassing.
An interesting point to this discussion is that many of the pros are argued by some to be disadvantages, and many of the cons are believed to be the advantages of the system by others. The founding fathers devised the electoral college to elect the president but they did not anticipate the emergence of national political parties or a communications network able to bring presidential candidates before the entire electorate. Here are some of the pros and cons of the electoral college. Some are quite liberal and others are very con servative. Pros and cons of electoral college flashcards quizlet. An elector is simply a person who elects someone else. The pros and cons of the electoral college smartasset. Students will then evaluate issues of fairness and representation with regard to the electoral college. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. The electoral college greatly helps to prevent this. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. I saw this video by the well liked by reddit youtuber cgp grey, he makes pretty good points on how the electoral college is flawed and what not. The debate over the continued use of the electoral college resurfaced during the 2016 presidential election, when donald trump lost the general election to hillary clinton by over 2.
Electoral college is a complicated and undemocratic system as viewed by some. The pros and cons of raising the minimum wage pro 2. Source for connecting students to college opportunitysuccess college actsat. The united states does not elect its presidents by a popular vote, but instead uses an electoral college process to select its leader, which may not. A collection of great sites for kids from the american library association collegeactsat. Every election year sparks debate over our electoral systems legitimacy, even though few fully understand how the electoral college works or why it exists. I still vote anyway and im free to vote for whoever i want for president, but a lot of people dont bother.
Here are some of the arguments for and against the electoral college. Pros and cons of the electoral college by corey bishop on prezi. Curabitur congue, odio vel faucibus interdum, felis magna euismod ante, id dignissim lectus libero id nisl. Hayes in 1876, and republican benjamin harrison in 1888. Constitution and structured by the 12th and 23rd amendments, the electoral college operates as a main apparatus for appointing both the president and vice president. We note that this year, arizona governor jan brewer voiced such an opinion. Apr 21, 2016 a look into the electoral college here are some of the more major pros and cons to the current practice. The electoral college pros and cons flashcards quizlet. Especially in contemporary times, urban areas tend to be more populated, but the electoral college saves the interests of. College in order to gain a better understanding of how americans elect the president.
389 1235 212 1512 1347 1520 38 1044 1160 1360 812 1061 1378 890 156 958 1354 381 273 833 15 537 600 1182 78 1309 969 98 511 594 1200 1173 862 892 1216 218 1026 1108 732 444 26 364 997 611 219